The Science of Mathematics uses research-based evidence about excellent mathematics programs, as well as significant obstacles and unproductive beliefs that continue to compromise progress for each and every student learning mathematics. The following resources may be useful for helping expose myths and other unproductive beliefs about the teaching and learning of mathematics.
NCTM's Beliefs About Teaching and Learning Mathematics
NCTM has produced numerous beliefs (Principles to Action, 2014) concerning the teaching and learning of mathematics from research that have impeded and promoted the learning of mathematics over the last two decades. Unfortunately, many of these unproductive beliefs still impede students' learning progress today.
Supporting Productive Struggle
Struggle does not mean "needless frustration" or "overly difficult" problems but problems within a student's zone of proximal development, as defined by Vygotsky (1978). The zone of proximal development is seen as an educational target just beyond what a student can do independently when provided appropriate support. This support may be from a teacher, parent, peer, tool or technology, and is engaged with prompts, questions, and modeling.
Inside Mathematics
Inside Mathematics is a professional resource for teachers, coaches, and administrators passionate about improving students’ mathematics learning and performance.
Illustrative Mathematics
Founded in 2011 at the University of Arizona, Illustrative Mathematics is guided and inspired by educators who work in spirited teams to do extraordinary things. The result is a comprehensive suite of math curricula, designed to encourage engaging mathematical discussion, supported by tasks, lesson plans, professional learning, and community.
Desmos
Desmos Studio is a Public Benefit Corporation with a goal of helping everyone learn math, love math, and grow with math. We believe that everyone has an inner mathematician and that some people haven’t been given the opportunity, encouragement, or tools to discover theirs. So we prioritize equity and accessibility at every level of our work. Strengths of Desmos may be found in ability to create and search teacher activities and the virtual/dynamic graphing calculator.
Geogebra
GeoGebra is a dynamic mathematics software for all levels of education that brings together geometry, algebra, spreadsheets, graphing, statistics and calculus in one engine. In addition, GeoGebra offers an online platform with over 1 million free classroom resources created by our multilingual community. These resources can be easily shared through our collaboration platform GeoGebra Classroom where student progress can be monitored in real time. Geogebra offers a dynamic way for students to experience and learn geometry within the classroom.
There is a “science of reading” that represents a convergence of evidence in the literacy research community about effective reading instruction. It is largely a descriptive phrase that represents a large (but not perfect) consensus about the findings from decades of reading research.
In contrast, the “Science of Math” is a branding (with a website and hashtag) of approaches to math instruction based on research from part of the special education research community, which in some cases disagrees with the findings of research by the “mainstream” mathematics education research community. The “Science of Math” claims to be a “movement” and is a way people are labeling themselves as a part of this special education community rather than a representation of a consensus.
Publication Comparisons
Recommendations from the Science of Mathematics vary across sources and specifically target research within the mathematics and statistics communities as opposed to the science of math.
Comparisons of Theory and Methods
The Science of Mathematics offers research from more diverse methods that increase learning on large scale and small scale with research that spans the domains of mathematical learning.
General Differences
The Science of Mathematics promotes teaching and learning of mathematics as an art of communication that builds students understanding in a Zone of Proximal Development where each student can be successful.
The science of math founders LACK of DIVERSITY with tangential roots to mathematics and mathematics education...
An interesting and important aspect of the "science of math" as compared to the "science of mathematics" is the founders background. Upon review of the founders of the "science of math", every individual credited with its foundation either specializes in "Special Education" or "Psychology". Much of the research coming from the "science of math" has presuppositions that undermine the very definition of mathematics. As one example, two of the founder's article Assessing the Instructional Level for Mathematics: A Comparison of Methods (Burns, VanDerHeyden, & Jiban, 2006) assumed that timed testing accuracy and fluency promotes higher SAT scores from a correlational study. Correlation does not imply causation.... They make implications from their study for the amount of basic facts that should be memorized through timed tests by special education students before they should be placed with general education students. Isolating students from their general education peers is not effective for special education students....
Guidelines for Assessment and Instruction in Statistics Education I
Guidelines for Assessment and Instruction in Statistics Education II
Statistical Education of Teachers
Principles to Action
Principles and Standards for School Mathematics
Catalyzing Change in High School Mathematics
The Mathematical Education of Teachers II
Asset Based Perspectives
Join researchers as they investigate Mathematical Meme's arising throughout culture: MathMemeTeam – mathematics identity memes social media.
Join researchers as they look to improve mathematics teacher education throughout the United States: Mathematics Teacher Education Partnership | CSMCE | Nebraska (unl.edu) .
Productive Struggle - Exploring the Latest Parenting Trend: Gentle Parenting, with Keith McCurdy - BaseCamp Live; What Is Productive Struggle in the Classroom? | HMH; Productive Math Struggle: Week 4 (Kevin Dykema)
Productive Struggle - Mathematics Teacher Educator Podcast Episode 53: Building Mathematics Professional Development With an Explicit Attention to Concepts and Student Opportunities to Struggle Framework
Building Procedural Fluency from Conceptual Understanding - Mathematics Teacher Educator Podcast Episode 16: Diverge then Converge: A Strategy for Deepening Understanding through Analyzing and Reconciling Contrasting Patterns of Reasoning
Using Mathematical Tools to Develop Deeper Mathematical Understanding - Mathematics Teacher Educator Podcast Episode 22: Interventions, Tools, and Equity-Oriented Resources in the MTE Journal; Manipulatives, Models, and Symbols: Representations for Building Number Sense - National Council of Teachers of Mathematics; Slide A Round Math Manipulatives
Focusing on Growth Mindset - Mathematics Teacher Educator Podcast Episode 36: Supporting Prospective Teachers in Problem Solving: Incorporating Mindset Messaging to Overcome Math Anxiety
Utilizing Formative Assessment - Mathematics Teacher Educator Podcast Episode 14: Supporting Teachers to Use Formative Assessment for Adaptive Decision Making
Differentiating Instruction - Differentiating Instruction in Math: It's Not as Hard as You Think - National Council of Teachers of Mathematics